Home » Healthy Nutrition » Healthy Diets

Pros and Cons of a High Carbohydrate Diet

High Carbohydrate Diet

  • Everyone is talking about the benefits of a low carb diet these days, but the opposite might actually be more effective
  • A diet high in carbohydrates can help you actually lose weight, with a new diet called the Bread for Life Diet
  • It really depends on the person, however, and a low carbohydrate diet might be a better option for some

Recently, a great deal of attention has been paid to high carbohydrate diets, specifically that they usually result in obesity or gain. A new diet on the scene boldly contradicts this commonly held diet belief. It’s called the Bread for Life Diet and it claims that eating foods not low, but high in carbohydrates, is the key to losing weight and keeping it off.

A general concept for weight loss is that expended energy in a set period must exceed the caloric intake equivalent. Basically, if more calories are being burned than are consumed, a body will be forced to lose weight.

But is a diet high in carbohydrates an effective means for weight loss?

The Bread for Life Diet

Olga Raz, creator of the Bread for Life Diet, bases her diet on the theory that high protein diets – commonly held as a solution to weight loss – lead to a drop in serotonin levels; whereas a higher consumption of carbohydrates would cause serotonin levels to increase. An increase in serotonin levels would increase metabolism and therefore aid in weight loss.

This is quite the idea reversal when compared to the popular Atkins Diet, which attributes its weight loss results to a low carbohydrate, high protein diet.

In general, most Western diets are usually high in carbohydrates, so high that virtually every meal causes substantial insulin production. If excess calories are not burned off, they will be stored in the body as fat.

The Cons of a High Carbohydrate Diet

A quick Google search shows that there are some medical considerations to be taken into account before starting a high carbohydrate diet.

Two studies, both conducted in Mexico, indicate a possibility of increased risks of pancreatic and breast cancers.
(Details of the first study can be found in the Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 2002; 94:1293-300.)

Mexico was chosen for these studies since dietary patterns there are often characterized by higher consumption of carbohydrates and lower intake of fat and animal proteins than those in more affluent Western countries.

Researchers speculate that impaired glucose tolerance may be to blame for these increased risks and that insulin may act as a growth factor for pancreatic cancer. The second study, carried out by a team of researchers from the Instituto de Salud P·blica in Cuernavaca, Mexico and the Harvard School of Public Health in Boston, also linked a diet high in carbohydrates to an increased risk for breast cancer. In this case control study of 1,866 women, it was found that those who received 57 or more percent of their total energy intake from carbohydrates incurred a risk of breast cancer 2.2 times greater than the women with more balanced diets.

These conclusions indicate that the link between carbohydrates and breast cancer may be related to elevated levels of insulin, insulin-like growth factor and binding proteins in the blood.

The Pros of a High Carbohydrate Diet

In a study of people who followed a diet high in carbohydrates, consisting of about 63 percent carbohydrates, 20 percent fat and 17 percent protein, the dieters lost, on average, 6 kilograms each over a 12-week period.

A diet high in carbohydrates is also useful for people with specific medical conditions. For example, those who suffer with acute porphyria, a disorder that affects the nervous system, are recommended to eat a diet consisting of 50 to 70 percent carbohydrates.

Another benefit to this diet is that foods high in carbohydrates, such as bread, pasta and rice, are often the most cheaply priced food items. Food items high in protein are often the highest priced.

The information supplied in this article is not to be considered as medical advice and is for educational purposes only.

No Responses to “Pros and Cons of a High Carbohydrate Diet”

  1. 1
    Katia Says:
    It’s funny that none of these diets ever mention an exercise program to go with them. Surely, one could eat a high-carb diet, and if an appropriate exercise program is performed along with it, the person will lose weight no matter what.
  2. 2
    Joey Says:
    This is a whole different take on dieting that I have read in a long time. So, what does this mean for the high-protein diet? Is the conclusion here that high-protein diets are not effective? Or just more harmful?